Why Russia Uses Invasions and Espionage, China Uses Economic Power and State Control, and Iran Uses Proxies and Ideology
By Huw Edwards
Throughout history, societies have faced a recurring political question: how should power be organised, exercised and restrained?
The answer offered by liberal democracy differs profoundly from the answer offered by authoritarianism.
Liberal democracies are built upon the belief that individual citizens possess rights that exist independently of the state. Governments derive legitimacy from the consent of the governed, political leaders can be peacefully removed, and power is constrained through institutions, laws and democratic accountability.
Authoritarian systems begin from a different premise. They tend to prioritise stability, control, national unity and regime preservation above individual liberty, political pluralism and open competition for power.
Today, three of the most influential authoritarian states in the world, Russia, China and Iran, demonstrate how different forms of authoritarianism can pursue remarkably similar goals through very different methods.
Russia often relies upon military force, covert operations and strategic disruption.
China frequently employs economic leverage, technological capability and extensive state control.
Iran projects influence through ideology, regional alliances and proxy organisations.
Understanding these differences, and the similarities beneath them, is essential if democracies are to understand the challenges of the twenty-first century.
The Authoritarian Mindset
Authoritarian systems place a high value on stability, control and political continuity.
Unlike liberal democracies, where governments change through open competition and criticism is accepted as a normal feature of political life, authoritarian systems frequently view dissent as a potential threat to state security. Freedom House consistently characterises Russia, China and Iran as political systems with significant restrictions on political rights and civil liberties.
This creates a distinctive political psychology.
Opposition becomes suspicious.
Independent media become problematic.
Civil society organisations become competing centres of influence.
External criticism becomes evidence of hostile intent.
Power becomes increasingly concentrated because those in authority begin to view challenges not as legitimate democratic participation but as threats requiring management, containment or suppression.
Liberty, Democracy and Human Flourishing
At their best, liberal democracies are founded upon a radically different idea.
They begin with the belief that every individual possesses inherent dignity and the capacity to think, choose and determine the direction of their own lives.
Political authority is not granted because rulers claim superior wisdom, religious authority or ideological correctness.
Instead, legitimacy flows upwards from citizens.
Freedom of thought allows individuals to question inherited assumptions and official narratives.
Freedom of conscience protects religious, philosophical and moral beliefs.
Freedom of expression enables criticism of governments and powerful institutions.
Freedom of association allows citizens to organise, innovate and advocate for change.
Democratic self-determination gives citizens a peaceful means of shaping the future of their societies.
These freedoms can make democracies appear messy.
Debates are often loud.
Elections create uncertainty.
Governments are criticised constantly.
Policies are challenged relentlessly.
Yet these apparent weaknesses are also among democracy’s greatest strengths.
Open societies possess mechanisms of self-correction. Bad ideas can be challenged. Corruption can be exposed. Failed leaders can be replaced without revolution or violence. Institutions can adapt because criticism is permitted rather than suppressed.
The philosopher Karl Popper argued that open societies derive strength from the ability to question authority and test ideas through reasoned debate. Closed societies, by contrast, often seek certainty through conformity and obedience.
However, liberty is not simply the freedom to do whatever one wishes.
A successful democratic society depends upon balancing rights with responsibilities.
Liberty cannot flourish if it destroys the liberty of others.
My freedom of speech should not silence yours.
My freedom of belief should not deny your freedom of conscience.
My freedom to pursue prosperity should not remove your opportunity to do likewise.
This principle has deep roots in liberal democratic thought. John Stuart Mill argued that liberty should be protected except where actions cause harm to others. The principle remains one of the foundations of modern democratic societies.
The most successful democracies recognise that freedom is not merely an individual possession.
It is a shared public good.
Rights and responsibilities exist together.
Rights without responsibility risk becoming selfishness.
Responsibility without rights becomes oppression.
This balance creates a democratic ecosystem where citizens enjoy freedom while respecting the equal freedoms of others.
Such systems are rarely perfect.
But they have repeatedly demonstrated a greater capacity for innovation, adaptation, accountability and peaceful social progress than systems built upon concentrated power and restricted dissent.
Russia: Power Through Fear, Force and Disruption
Modern Russia derives much of its strategic worldview from history.
Repeated invasions, imperial collapse and geopolitical insecurity have contributed to a political culture in which strength, security and national resilience are frequently prioritised above political liberalisation.
According to Freedom House, power in modern Russia is highly concentrated around the presidency, with restrictions on opposition activity, independent media and political dissent.
Externally, Russia has increasingly relied upon a combination of military intervention, intelligence operations, cyber activities, espionage, disinformation campaigns and covert influence operations.
NATO and the UK House of Commons Library describe Russia as a significant practitioner of hybrid warfare, combining military power with propaganda, cyber operations, political interference and strategic disruption.
Russia’s objectives appear to include:
- Preserving regime security.
- Maintaining regional influence.
- Preventing perceived strategic encirclement.
- Reasserting great-power status.
- Challenging aspects of Western geopolitical influence.
Russia’s approach seeks influence through strategic leverage, coercion and disruption.
In effect, it often uses fear and instability as instruments of statecraft.
China: Power Through Wealth, Technology and Control
China presents a different model of authoritarianism.
While Russia frequently projects military power, China’s influence increasingly flows through economics, technology, trade, investment and state-directed development.
The Chinese Communist Party has overseen one of the most significant economic transformations in modern history, lifting hundreds of millions of people out of poverty while simultaneously maintaining strict political control.
Rather than political liberalisation accompanying economic development, China has developed sophisticated systems of surveillance, censorship and state oversight.
Analysts at Chatham House describe aspects of this model as “smart authoritarianism”, combining technological innovation with centralised political control.
China’s goals appear to include:
- Preserving Communist Party rule.
- Maintaining social and political stability.
- Expanding technological leadership.
- Increasing geopolitical influence.
- Reducing reliance on foreign technologies and strategic vulnerabilities.
Researchers at CSIS have argued that China increasingly uses economic statecraft and economic pressure as instruments of foreign policy, leveraging trade relationships and market access to shape the behaviour of other states.
Unlike Russia, China’s preferred weapon is often not military force but economic centrality.
Its influence grows when other nations become dependent upon its markets, products, capital and supply chains.
The objective is often not conquest but indispensability.
Iran: Power Through Ideology and Proxies
Iran represents a third authoritarian model.
Unable to match the economic strength of China or the military reach of Russia, the Islamic Republic developed alternative methods of projecting power.
Since the 1979 Revolution, Iran has invested heavily in regional alliances, ideological networks and proxy organisations.
According to the Council on Foreign Relations, Iran has constructed an extensive network of allied groups across the Middle East to advance its regional interests and strategic objectives.
The Wilson Center similarly documents Iranian support for organisations operating across multiple countries through training, funding and logistical assistance.
Iran’s objectives appear to include:
- Preserving the Islamic Republic.
- Expanding regional influence.
- Countering rival powers.
- Supporting aligned movements.
- Promoting what Iranian leaders describe as the “Axis of Resistance.”
Rather than projecting power through large-scale invasions, Iran frequently projects influence through intermediaries, allowing Tehran to shape regional events whilst reducing the costs and risks associated with direct military confrontation.
Different Methods, Similar Goals
Russia sends soldiers.
China sends salesmen.
Iran sends proxies.
Yet despite these differences, all three systems display several recurring authoritarian themes.
Regime Survival
The preservation of the existing political order is often treated as the highest priority.
Challenges to governing authority become security concerns rather than democratic disagreements.
Concentration of Power
Authority becomes concentrated within political elites, ruling parties, security institutions or leadership structures.
Checks and balances are weakened.
Independent scrutiny becomes limited.
Information Control
Control of information becomes strategically important.
Media, communication and public narratives are managed to varying degrees in support of political stability.
National Influence
Each seeks to shape events beyond its borders and expand its influence within its surrounding region and the wider international system.
Resistance to External Pressure
All three challenge aspects of a liberal democratic, Western-led international order that they perceive as inconsistent with their interests or threatening to regime security.
Authoritarian Creep Beyond Authoritarian States
It would be a mistake to believe these dynamics exist only in Russia, China or Iran.
Authoritarian creep can occur within democratic societies as well.
The process rarely begins with tanks in the streets or the abolition of elections.
It more often begins with rhetoric.
Political opponents become enemies.
Journalists become traitors.
Courts become obstacles.
Facts become negotiable.
Criticism becomes disloyalty.
Gradually, the culture of democracy begins to weaken.
The greatest danger is not that democracies become authoritarian overnight.
The greater danger is that citizens become comfortable with the slow erosion of democratic norms so long as it appears to deliver security, certainty or partisan advantage.
History repeatedly demonstrates that freedom is rarely lost all at once.
It is weakened incrementally.
Final Thoughts
Russia, China and Iran represent different expressions of authoritarian power.
Russia frequently relies upon military force, espionage and strategic disruption.
China relies heavily upon economic influence, technological capability and state control.
Iran relies upon ideology, proxy networks and regional alliances.
Their methods differ.
Their histories differ.
Their ideologies differ.
Yet they share a common conviction that stability, control and concentrated authority are preferable to the uncertainties of liberal democracy.
Liberal democracies offer a different vision.
They place their trust not in rulers but in citizens.
Not in uniformity but in pluralism.
Not in obedience but in participation.
Not in state-directed truth but in open inquiry and debate.
The strength of democracy is not that it eliminates disagreement.
The strength of democracy is that it allows disagreement to exist without violence.
It allows societies to change leaders without revolution.
It allows citizens to challenge authority without fear.
It allows individuals to think, believe, speak and organise freely while recognising that those same freedoms belong equally to others.
That balance between liberty and responsibility remains one of humanity’s greatest political achievements.
The challenge of the twenty-first century is not merely understanding the ambitions of authoritarian states abroad.
It is ensuring that democratic societies remain confident in the values that have historically given free people the power to shape their own futures.
References and Further Reading
United Nations, Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948).
Freedom House – Russia Country Profile.
Freedom House – Global Freedom Reports.
NATO – Countering Hybrid Threats.
NATO – Information Threats and Disinformation.
UK House of Commons Library – Russia’s Hybrid Warfare Campaign in Europe.
Chatham House – China’s Smart Authoritarianism.
CSIS – China’s Economic Statecraft and Economic Coercion.
Council on Foreign Relations – Iran’s Regional Armed Network.
Wilson Center – Iran’s Islamist Proxies in the Middle East.
Karl Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945).
John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859).







You must be logged in to post a comment.